Gowrath vs. Sellertoolkit vs Sellerboard: Which Amazon Profit & Loss App is Best for You?

Every successful Amazon seller eventually moves from guessing their profit to demanding clarity. The market for profit analytics tools is dominated by a few big names, but finding the right one can make or break your ability to scale.
We're breaking down the three top choices—Sellerboard, SellerToolKit, and GoWrath—to help you decide which one best suits your business stage, budget, and need for deep financial truth.
| Feature | Sellerboard | SellerToolKit | GoWrath |
| Primary Focus | Analytics & Automation | Reconciliation & Repricing | Purest Profit Clarity & Granular COGS Tracking |
| Core Value | Broad feature set (PPC, Reviews, Inventory) | Specialized reimbursement and pricing tools | Large feature set including reimbursements tracking and emphasizing on eliminating all P&L blind spots instantly. |
| Pricing Model | Tiered by Orders/Month (Starts low) | Tiered by Orders/Month (Can be add-on heavy) | Tiered by Orders/Month (Starts low) |
| COGS Tracking | Supports batch tracking. | Strong FIFO (First In, First Out) support. | Advanced Multi-Cost/Multi-Batch Management. Crucial for accurate margins. |
| Real-Time Data | High frequency, near real-time. | High frequency, near real-time. | High frequency, near real-time. |
| Reimbursement Tool | Yes (Automated error detection). | Yes, with reconciliation templates | Advanced reimbursements, scanning line data discrepancies (Refunds missing etc.,) along with shipments. |
1. Sellerboard

Sellerboard is often the first tool sellers graduate to after leaving spreadsheets. It is the definition of a comprehensive "Amazon tool suite" built around profit analytics.
The Sellerboard Advantage:
Broad Feature Set: Beyond P&L, Sellerboard includes PPC optimization, automated review requests, and inventory alerts. It aims to replace multiple tools.
Affordable Starting Price: Their lowest tiers are very budget-friendly, making it great for newer sellers with low order volume who want many tools in one place.
Solid Dashboard: The profit dashboard is clear, customizable, and gives a good overall view of your business health.
The Trade-Off:
Order-Based Scaling: As you grow, their pricing scales steeply. Once you cross into higher order volumes (e.g., 6,000+ orders/month), the monthly cost can jump significantly.
Generalist Approach: While it does many things well, some specialized features (like deep COGS granularity or sophisticated repricing) can feel less robust than dedicated tools.
2. SellerToolKit (STK)

SellerToolKit shines where Amazon's reporting fails the most: lost revenue. It is particularly popular among wholesale and arbitrage sellers due to its focus on reconciliation.
The SellerToolKit Advantage:
Best-in-Class Reconciliation: If you have high inventory movement, STK is hard to beat for automatically identifying FBA errors (lost units, missed returns) and providing the exact templates to claim your money back.
Integrated Repricer: Having a repricer that works directly off your required profit/ROI (not just the lowest price) is a powerful combination for many sellers.
Strong COGS Handling (FIFO): Excellent for inventory accuracy, a must-have for those with frequently changing supplier costs.
The Trade-Off:
P&L Secondary: While it does P&L, the core strength is reconciliation and inventory. Sellers focused purely on financial analysis might find the profit dashboard less intuitive or less detailed than dedicated competitors.
Add-On Costs: Key features like the advanced Repricer are often a separate, significant add-on fee, making the true cost higher than the base plan suggests.
3. GoWrath
GoWrath was created by sellers who were frustrated that even the "all-in-one" tools required manual effort to achieve 100% accurate P&L. We focus on providing the absolute truth about your business's financial health by integrating best-in-class features with superior precision.

The GoWrath Advantage
1. Unrivaled Financial Accuracy (The True P&L)
Superior COGS Flexibility: Our unique COGS engine is built to handle the most complex scenarios: Multi-Batch Costs (buying at $5 then $4), Pre-Paid Fixed Costs (factory molds, photography fees), and Amortized Expenses (office rent, VAs). We apply these costs per unit based on advanced rules, ensuring your margin is always precise.
No More "Guesstimated" Profit: We provide a clean, instantly updated view of your Net Profit without relying on manual entry for critical, variable costs.
2. Maximum Cash Recovery (Beyond Templates)
- Line-by-Line Reimbursement Auditing: We don't just alert you to errors—we conduct a full forensic audit. GoWrath finds discrepancies in missing customer refunds, inconsistent shipment counts, and every other fee overcharge, giving you the detailed proof needed for Seller Support to maximize your cash recovery.
3. Future-Proof Technology (AI-Driven Scaling)
- Coming Soon: AI-Powered PPC: Forget basic bid automation. GoWrath is bringing next-generation PPC to the market with Real-Time AI Insights that optimize campaigns based on your actual Net Profit (not just ACoS), fully automating the scale process.
4. Predictable, Growth-Friendly Pricing
- Flat-Rate Peace of Mind: Our model is designed to support high-growth sellers without punitive order-based fees. You can scale your sales to the moon without automatically getting hit by the next pricing tier penalty.
The Trade-Off: Zero Distractions
- Focused Interface: We do not clutter your dashboard with non-essential tools like automated review requests. Our philosophy is that top brands use dedicated, best-in-class tools for things like reviews; GoWrath is your best-in-class financial core.
The Verdict: Which Tool Should You Choose?
| Your Seller Profile | Choose This Tool | Why |
| New seller to advanced seller, Wholesale, OA, RA, PL/Brand owner | GoWrath | You need financial precision for budgeting and reordering, best-in-class reimbursement recovery, and a platform that is ready for the future of AI-driven optimization without punitive pricing tiers. |
| New seller to advanced seller PL/Brand owner | Sellerboard | The low entry cost provides great initial utility for very small, single-account sellers who need basic functions. |
| New seller to intermediate seller, Wholesale, OA, RA. | SellerToolKit | The heavy focus on reconciliation and high-volume, quick inventory turnover is critical for this business model. |
Stop choosing between features and accuracy. GoWrath gives you every essential feature, superior precision on your numbers, and a clear path to AI-driven growth.
Ready to Use Your Financial Data to Outsmart the Competition?
Click here to start your free trial of GoWrath.com and gain full financial clarity today.